Natural Gas

Corporate interest outranks public interest

This news release from the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives (CCPA) is worth repeating. Many citizens — although not In-Sights readers — will be shocked to learn that credits owed natural gas producers soared by more than $1 billion from April to November 2017.

That increase is two and a half times more than the total gas royalties received by government in the three fiscal years ended March 2018. The $3.2 billion balance owed to producers ensures that royalty revenues will remain at paltry levels throughout the Horgan Government’s present term.

welfare 480

This is the CCPA release:

CCPA calls on Auditor General to investigate stunning $1-billion annual increase in provincial natural gas-drilling subsidy program

MAY 31, 2018
VANCOUVER – An unprecedented increase in a special “credit” account set up by the BC government to subsidize the fracking industry should be immediately investigated by the province’s Auditor General, says the BC office of the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives.

In November 2017, BC’s Minister of Energy, Mines and Petroleum Resources said the balance in the “deep well credit” account was $3.2 billion. But according to the BC Public Accounts, in March 2017 the balance was $2.15 billion.

The increase is by far the largest ever recorded yet, to date, the ministry has declined to explain the sudden surge in the account balance.

The increase is more than double the previous annual increase, leading the CCPA to ask BC’s independent Auditor General to investigate the unusual increase and whether or not figures published by the government on the account balances are accurate.

The account represents the value of “credits” that the Province allows fossil fuel companies to deduct from royalty payments to public coffers. Fossil fuel companies use the credits to dramatically reduce the royalties they pay to the Province for the wells they drill and frack.

In the past 10 years, the Province’s credit programs translated into $4.9 billion in savings for those companies and correspondingly large foregone revenues to the Province.

“The ugly truth is that in 10 years we’ve produced more fossil fuels than ever while the royalties we received went into the toilet,” says Ben Parfitt, a resource policy analyst with the BC office of the CCPA.

“All of that foregone $4.9 billion, plus the foregone revenues in the $3.2-billion credit account, plus any future credits claimed by the industry translates into reduced services for school kids, hospital patients, transit users, people who are homeless, First Nations, you name it,” he explained.

Largely because of those credits, revenues collected from fossil fuel companies have fallen steadily. In the last 10 years, as natural gas production in BC shot up 72 per cent, royalty revenues collected from fossil fuel companies went in the opposite direction. In 2007-2008, royalty revenues were $1.16 billion. By 2016-2017, they were just $147 million.

That 87-per-cent decline in royalty payments meant that in the most recent year for which information is available, British Columbians received only 3.6% of the market value in royalties for the natural gas extracted in the province. By comparison, citizens in the United States saw a return of 12.5 per cent on gas produced on federally owned lands.

The CCPA repeatedly asked the Ministry of Energy to explain why the credit account ballooned so quickly, but the Ministry’s eventual response raised even more questions than it answered.

“It’s not due to expanded natural gas industry activity,” David Haslam, the Ministry’s director of communications, said in an email. Haslam added that the published credit account balance as reported annually in Public Accounts may, in fact, not fully capture the value of all outstanding credits.

“The public accounts figure represents the most likely to be used in the future,” Haslam said.

This response is inadequate, Parfitt said.

“That is why we have asked the Auditor General to investigate this subsidy scheme and what lies behind the massive increase in the account this past year,” he said. “If the increase is not due to ‘expanded natural gas industry activity’, then what other explanation is there? This is a publicly owned resource. How many billions of dollars have we actually given away to these companies?

“In addition, when the Ministry says that the published credit figures reflect those credits that are ‘most likely’ to be used, the clear inference is that someone in government is making a judgment call. How many more credits are out there that might be claimed? Why aren’t those other credits publicly accounted for? The Auditor General is best positioned to get the answers to such questions,” Parfitt said.

ccpa2 480

gas royalties

Categories: Natural Gas

Tagged as:

10 replies »

  1. We traded one corrupt government for another. Is it any wonder so many of us no longer vote? Corruption in politics rules.


  2. I guess it is time to call the meeting of all to order.
    Did the NDP know the scale of the deception in 2017? If they did not, how come? If they did, why is it being perpetrated? Accountability starts now, so what happens next?


  3. If the (arguably suspect) excuse the NDP proffered to explain proceeding with the Site C project was reduced by $1 billion, it would have destroyed the already shaky excuse.

    It appears that in the NDP’s world $1 billion is sufficient to cause a monumental shift in direction in one case, and in another that amount isn’t worth talking about.

    Unexplained disparities like those cause people to start imagining motives. And since politicians are already at the bottom of the “which professions do you trust” polls, Mr. Horgan and the NDP are unlikely to receive the benefit of any doubt.

    Lest the public starts to imagine Mr. Horgan is untrustworthy some explanations are in order.


  4. Just wondering: would this kind of trickery be of interest to the Americans, who cry foul over our “subsidized” stumpage rates in the forestry sector? Tarriffs on BC gas exports coming?


  5. Like the USA, Canada has been taken over by the criminal elites, who control politicians and governments.

    The criminal elites only goal is to make money, thus casino money laundering, real estate illegalities, and market manipulations are the order of the day.

    Welcome to 2018, based on the timid 1984, a very brave new world we live in.


  6. these corporations receive a billion here and there and we still don’t have enough schools or affordable housing. My suggestion, give the companies a phone call advising the kids in this province are more of priority and they can go screw themselves waiting for the money, its not coming. Thanks el gordo and Christy for screwing the kids of this province.


  7. Citizens who are in need or have to deal with economic hardship are called welfare bums, but when a business does so it is conveniently overlooked and never referred to as “Corporate welfare”, why? The corporate welfare recipients get taken care of but many of our most marginalized are ignored, why?


Leave a reply but be on topic and civil.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s